Jewish Social Policy Action Network

In This Issue:
Newsletter: September 19, 2008
Point - Counterpoint: On Settlement Expansion Beyond the Green Line
In early August, Meretz USA for Israeli Civil Rights and Peace, a progressive Zionist organization that supports peace between the State of Israel and its neighbors based on a negotiated land-for-peace solution, invited those American Jews who believe that settlement expansion is a disastrous policy to send a prepared letter to Israeli Housing Minister Ze'ev Boim. The letter urged Minister Boim to cancel plans to build more housing in three settlements beyond the Green LIne: Ramat Shlomo, Har Homa and Pisgat Zeev.

Mr. Boim has invited construction bids for more than 2,000 housing units in all three settlements, despite protests from the U.S. State Department. The settlements are in areas captured by Israel in the 1967 War, on the outskirts of Jerusalem. The Meretz letter states that the action asking for construction tenders "sends the wrong message to Palestinians, who are losing their faith in Israel's commitment to a viable two-state solution."

As of this date, the JSPAN Board has not taken any position on this issue. However, the Board decided to use this opportunity to ask two activists in the Philadelphia Jewish community, whose views on settlement expansion are widely divergent, to articulate their opinions for this newsletter. We encourage our readers to voice their own opinions as well. Click here to share your thoughts.

Please note that both Steve Masters and Lori Lowenthal Marcus are identified through their affiliations for informational purposes only and were not asked to write the following essays on behalf of their respective groups.


Point: Peace Demands An End to the Tragedy of the Settlements
by Steve Masters, Philadelphia attorney and president, Brit Tzedek v'Shalom, the Jewish Alliance for Justice and Peace

I support Israel. I always have, and I daresay I always will. I believe in the right of the Jewish people to a national home, and I love the home we’ve built. I’ve lived there, worked there, found friends and loved ones there.

But I long ago learned that supporting Israel can’t mean unconditional acceptance of official policy. One can love a place and still question its leaders. Indeed, sometimes that is exactly what love demands. When it comes to Israel’s settlement policies, that’s the kind of love I hold in my heart – the kind that questions, and demands change.

Simply put, the settlements represent one of the greatest threats to security of the Jewish State.

There are many reasons this is so. Israeli soldiers on settlement duty aren’t available to defend the country’s borders; money spent on settlement defense is money taken from Israel’s other military needs; time and resources spent preparing soldiers for such duty mean less training for conventional wars (a fact we saw play out to Israel’s detriment in the course of the 2006 Second War in Lebanon).

[read more]

Counterpoint: Who Is Disturbed, and Why?
by Lori Lowenthal Marcus, Philadelphia-area lawyer, journalist whose focus is the Middle East and past president of the Greater Philadelphia District of the Zionist Organization of America

Denying basic human rights to any ethnic group on the basis of membership in that group is surely anathema to all who believe in the fundamental dignity of human beings. For any government to refuse the right of residence, employment, security or reproduction (refusal to allow families to house their offspring is tantamount to a denial of reproduction), or even breathing rights, to a populace based on their membership in an ethnic or other group constitutes the most blatant form of racist discrimination.

And yet the Meretz opposition to the construction of new homes in Judea and Samaria, and so the one being addressed in these opposing essays, turns the quest for justice and fairness on its head.

Meretz demands that we adopt and endorse the Arab Palestinian leadership’s racist policy officially denying Jews the right to reside in, be employed in, be secure in, or even breathe in, the territories under dispute. If we are really concerned about the safety of Israel and of the United States, as Meretz claims is its motivation in making this request of us, wouldn’t they be asking us to vehemently oppose the racist operative documents and actions of the ruling Arab Palestinian parties requiring that the area in dispute be judenrein?

[read more]

 

Save the Date for JSPAN's Fourth Social Justice Award!
The Fourth Social Justice Award of the Jewish Social Policy Action Network will be presented on Tuesday, December 9, 2008 to community activists Dan and Sheila Segal. The award presentation and reception will take place at the Independence Visitor Center in Philadelphia. More details will follow!

 

Last Call for JSPAN Holiday Cards
Only a limited number of JSPAN cards with a special inscription for Rosh Hashanah are still available: 7 for $20. Call (215)635-2554 to place your order now!

 

In Anticipation of the New Year: A Light Moment
There is a ceremony called Tashlich, meaning "casting off," a long- standing Jewish practice performed on the afternoon of Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year. The previous year's sins are symbolically cast off, by throwing pieces of bread, or a similar food item, into a large natural body of flowing water, such as a river, lake, sea or ocean. The name "Tashlich", and the practice itself, are derived from the Biblical passage (Micah 7:18-20) recited at the ceremony: "You will cast all of their sins into the depth of the sea." Symbolically, the fish devour the sins.

Occasionally, people ask what kind of bread crumbs should be thrown. In the spirit of starting the New Year with a smile, here are some suggestions for breads which may be most appropriate for specific sins and misbehaviors:

For ordinary sins
White Bread

For erotic sins
French Bread

For particularly dark sins
Pumpernickel

For complex sins
Multi-Grain

For twisted sins
Pretzels

For tasteless sins
Rice Cakes

For sins of indecision
Waffles

For sins committed in haste
Matzoh

For sins of chutzpah
Fresh Bread

For substance abuse
Stoned Wheat

For use of heavy drugs
Poppy Seed

For petty larceny
Stollen

For committing auto theft
Caraway

For timidity/cowardice
Milk Toast

For ill-temperedness
Sourdough

For silliness, eccentricity
Nut Bread

For not giving full value
Shortbread

For jingoism, chauvinism
Yankee Doodles

For excessive irony
Rye Bread

For unnecessary chances
Hero Bread

For telling bad jokes/puns
Corn Bread

For war-mongering
Kaiser Rolls

For dressing immodestly
Tarts

For causing injury to others
Tortes

For lechery and promiscuity
Hot Buns

For promiscuity with gentiles
Hot Cross Buns

For racist attitudes
Crackers

For sophisticated racism
Ritz Crackers

For being holier than thou
Bagels

For abrasiveness
Grits

For dropping in without notice
Popovers

For over-eating
Stuffing

For impetuosity
Quick Bread

For indecent photography
Cheesecake

For raising your voice too often
Challah

For pride and egotism
Puff Pastry

For sycophancy, ass-kissing
Brownies

For being overly smothering
Angel Food Cake

For laziness
Any long loaf

For trashing the environment
Dumplings

 

JSPAN Finds Possible Church-State Violation in Juneau, Alaska
With Sarah Palin very much in the news these days over her willingness to see government carry out directives from God, a lot is being written about how Alaska politics really works.

One obscure news report caught JSPAN's attention. It seems that this past May, Governor Palin delivered a $25,000 check from the State of Alaska to the Juneau Christian Center (the JCC in local terms), an Assemblies of God church where she sometimes worships. The money was to be used to assist the Hub, a youth program associated with the church, in building a teen center on the JCC premises. According to the JCC web site, it appears that the teen center is part of an outreach program designed to proselytize. The Hub is listed with the IRS as a 501(c)(3) religious organization, as is the JCC.

Curious about why government money would be used to subsidize such a program, JSPAN began to gather information about what strings, if any, were placed on the use of these funds. Is government money being used to support the religious activities of a religious institution? As part of this effort, JSPAN President Jeff Pasek submitted a formal request under Alaska's Open Records Law to Emil Notti, the State Commissioner of Commerce, Community and Economic Development in Juneau, requesting copies of documents relating to "all requests for funding submitted since January 1, 2007 by or on behalf of the Hub Youth Center," as well as "all documents generated by or on behalf of your agency with respect to the .... Center."

As of this date, JSPAN has not received a reply from Commissioner Notti.

 

Do Clergy Have a Constitutional Right to Endorse Political Candidates from their Pulpits?
The Alliance Defense Fund (ADF), a legal consortium founded in 1994 by Christian conservatives, is dedicated to underwriting legal battles and training lawyers to move the United States in socially conservative directions. Among its initiatives in recent years have been helping the Boy Scouts ban gay Scout leaders and challenging same-sex marriage initiatives, stem cell research and rules that limit the distance protesters must keep from abortion patients.

Now the ADF is taking on the Internal Revenue Service. And rather than waiting for the IRS to investigate an alleged violation, the Fund is directly challenging the rules that govern tax-exempt organizations.

According to an article by Peter Slevin, Washington Post staff writer, which appeared in that paper on September 8, 2008, the ADF is recruiting three dozen pastors from more than 20 states to endorse political candidates from their pulpits on September 28. "The effort is designed to trigger an IRS investigation that ADF lawyers would then challenge in federal court. The ultimate goal is to persuade the U.S. Supreme Court to throw out a 54-year-old ban on political endorsements by tax-exempt houses of worship."

On the other side of the issue, however, are "an opposing collection of Christian and Jewish clergy (who consider) the ADF's 'Pulpit Initiative' an assault on the rule of law and the separation of church and state." A counter effort has been organized "call(ing) for hundreds of clergy to preach on September 21 about the value of the separation of church and state."

To read "Ban on Political Endorsements by Pastors Targeted" by Peter Slevin, click here.

 

A Farewell to our Philadelphia JCRC Executive Director

 

JSPAN Continues to Call for Health Care Reform in Pennsylvania
The Jewish Social Policy Action Network has been engaged for several years in the ongoing discussion about the pressing need for health care reform in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. As a member of the Pennsylvania Health Access Network (PHAN), JSPAN has been in regular communication with legislators from both the State House and the Senate, to keep them informed about the ever-changing landscape of legislation pertaining to health care issues.

On September 8, 2008, a letter on behalf of JSPAN was sent to state senators, urging them "to put aside partisan differences ..... to achieve a bipartisan consensus on health care reform recommendations before the General Assembly."

To read the JSPAN letter to state senators, click here.

 

Steven L. Spiegel: How to Hand Off the Peace Process to Our Next President
Steven L. Spiegel is a professor of political science, director of the Center for Middle East Development at the University of California, Los Angeles and a national scholar of the Israel Policy Forum. In an op-ed column which was published in the Jewish Forward on September 4, 2008, Professor Spiegel opines on the current dilemma facing the Middle East peace process: the most important players involved in cobbling together an agreement are about to leave office, or, in the case of Mahmoud Abbas, threatening to resign.

"One option left for the Bush Administration," explains Professor Spiegel, "is to craft a Bush-Olmert-Abbas statement detailing agreements reached to date, .... (but) there does not seem to be sufficient time left to complete enough details, even if the parties were prepared to do so." However, according to Professor Spiegel, there are several steps that the Bush administration can take in the next few months to "advance prospects for an eventual peace accord."

"The most important contribution Bush and Rice can make .... is to bequeath to their successors the sense that progress is possible in the Israeli-Palestinian arena if they quickly devote time, attention and political and diplomatic capital to it. .... A positive series of joint messages - either public or confidential - by the Palestinians and Israelis that communicated confidence in the future and invited the new president to continue and even accelerate his activities on their behalf would be critical in shaping the thinking of the transition team."

To read "How to Hand Off the Peace Process to Our Next President" by Steven L. Spiegel, click here.

 

Hunger Relief Advocacy in Philadelphia Region: The Mitzvah Food Project

The Mitzvah Food Project is coordinated by the Mitzvah Projects Task Force of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia. It was launched in 1996 to alleviate hunger and malnutrition among at-risk families in the Greater Philadelphia region and provides ongoing food relief to vulnerable households once or twice monthly, with emergency provisions available as needed. The project works in partnership with volunteers and community groups, spearheaded by synagogues and Jewish organizations.

A major challenge facing food programs across the country is diminishing Federal and State funding. The Mitzvah Food Project is experiencing this first hand as it continues to expand to meet the growing demand for services in a dangerous climate of increasing food prices.

In the 2006-07 program year, the Project supplemented 67% of its food costs with support from the State Food Purchase Program. This program incurred a $150,000 – 5% -- budget cut this year. The full impact of this budget cut on The Project is not yet known.

Compounding this budget cut is the fact that the Consumer Price Index for food increased 4% in 2007, the highest annual increase since 1990, and as a result The Project experienced a surge in demand for hunger-relief services. Over the first six months of the 2007-08 program year, The Project served 30% more households than last year to meet this demand.

The ability of the Project to continue to provide food and basic staples to those in need will depend upon increased support from the community. You can help the Mitzvah Food Project meet these increasing needs by becoming a hunger relief advocate.

For more information about the work of the Mitzvah Food Project, contact Drisana Davis, Mitzvah Food Project coordinator, at ddavis@philafederation.org or (215)832-0531.

Join the Mitzvah Food Project Advocacy Net for updates and calls-to-action.

 

The Obamas Have a Rabbi in the Family
The Jewish Forward, in an article by Anthony Weiss on September 4, 2008, profiled Rabbi Capers Funnye, spiritual leader of the Beth Shalom B'nai Zaken Ethiopian Hebrew Congregation in southwest Chicago. Rabbi Funnye is vice-president of the Israelite Board of Rabbis, the rabbinical association for black Israelite rabbis, and a member of the Chicago Board of Rabbis. He also happens to be a first cousin once removed of Michelle Obama. Mr. Weiss explains how, "in this presidential campaign, Funnye's famous relative gives an unexpected twist to the much analyzed relationship between Barack Obama and the Jewish community."

JSPAN has a clear policy of non-partisanship on political issues and does NOT endorse candidates for office. The editorial committee of this newsletter determined, however, that it was appropriate to include this article because of the large numbers of e-mails that have been circulating on the internet in recent months raising questions about Senator Obama's relationship to the Jewish community. JSPAN invites its readers to let us know if any of the other candidates for national office have Jewish relatives, so that we can share this information with our readers.


The Obamas Have a Rabbi in the Family
Cousin of Candidate’s Wife Leads Synagogue on Chicago’s South Side
By Anthony Weiss

While Barack Obama has struggled to capture Jewish votes, it turns out that one of his wife’s cousins is the country’s most prominent black rabbi.

Michelle Obama, wife of the Democratic presidential nominee, is a first cousin once removed of Rabbi Capers Funnye, spiritual leader of a mostly black synagogue on Chicago’s South Side. Funnye’s mother, Verdelle Robinson Funnye, and Michelle Obama’s paternal grandfather, Frasier Robinson Jr., were brother and sister.

Funnye (pronounced fuh-NAY) is the chief rabbi of the Beth Shalom B’nai Zaken Ethiopian Hebrew Congregation in southwest Chicago. He is well known in Jewish circles for acting as a bridge between mainstream Jewry and the much smaller, and largely separate, world of black Jewish congregations, sometimes known as black Hebrews, or Israelites. He has often urged the larger Jewish community to be more accepting of Jews who are not white.

In this presidential campaign, Funnye’s famous relative gives an unexpected twist to the much analyzed relationship between Barack Obama and the Jewish community. On the one hand, Jewish political organizers, voters and donors — including some of the city’s wealthiest and most prominent families — played an essential role in Obama’s rise to power in Chicago. But the Illinois senator has struggled to overcome suspicions in some parts of the Jewish community, including skepticism about his stance on Israel, and discredited but persistent rumors that he is secretly a Muslim.

[read more]

 

Support JSPAN
 

Please remember that JSPAN welcomes your donations to help us continue our important and effective work in Tikkun Olam. You may send gifts via PayPal on www.jspan.org. or to JSPAN, 1735 Market Street, Suite #A417, Philadelphia, PA 19103

 

Want to Join?
To become a voting JSPAN member, please go to www.JSPAN.org. On the right side of your screen you will be able to start a secure transaction and become a voting member.

 

Make all checks payable to:
JSPAN
1735 Market Street, Suite #A417
Philadelphia, PA 19103

 

JSPAN Officers
Jeffrey Pasek
President

Kenneth Fox
Vice President

Kenneth Myers
Vice President

Stephen Applebaum
Treasurer

Joel Beaver
Assistant Treasurer

Stewart Weintraub
Secretary & General Counsel

Directors:
Susan Myers, Chair
Alex Urevick
Ackelsberg
Irwin Aronson
Susan Bolno
Adam Bonin
David S. Broida
Deanne Comer
Hon. Ruth Damsker
Marshall Dayan
William Epstein
Helen Fox
Brian Gralnick
Rabbi Elliot Holin
Jerome Kaplan
Jennifer Kates
Lazar Kleit
Judah Labovitz
Ruth Laibson
Rabbi Robert Layman
Spencer Lempert
Daniel Loeb
Theodore Mann
Norm Newberg
Maureen Pelta
Adena Potok
Ruth Schultz
Randy Schulz
Daniel Segal
Burt Siegel
Rabbi David Straus
Rabbi Joshua Waxman

Executive Director:
Mort Levine

Editor:
Ruth Laibson

 

 
The newsletter contains articles and links to articles that we think will be of interest to JSPAN members. They are included for informational purposes, but unless otherwise stated, they do not necessarily reflect official JSPAN policy.

As an organization for change, JSPAN strives to advance progressive social policies on the critical issues of our time. Help spread the news about us by forwarding this email and the link to our website http://www.jspan.org to your family, friends, and colleagues who might have an interest in joining JSPAN or serving on any of JSPAN's projects. If you haven't joined JSPAN, please join now!